[Note: This is the 11th post in our “Papers in Brief” series. This series offers a special service as it explains the core ideas of chosen research papers in a nutshell.]
Papers in Brief (XI) by Florian Lüdeke-Freund
Breuer, H. & Lüdeke-Freund, F. (2017): Values-Based Network and Business Model Innovation, International Journal of Innovation Management, Vol. 21, No. 3, Art. 1750028 (35 pages).
Innovation management falls short in solving urgent societal problems, if it neglects the power of networks and the values of their constituent actors. Even though network and business model innovation have been acknowledged as innovation categories in their own right, their problem-solving potential remains unexplored.
In this article, we argue that purposeful innovation requires considering the shared values of those engaging in innovation processes, where values are understood as subjective notions of the desirable. Values-based innovation can motivate the development of new networks and business models that address complex societal problems, such as the unsustainability of current forms of energy supply.
We present a theoretical framework and facilitation methods for values-based network and business model innovation. Both have been applied in an exemplary workshop on regional energy networks in Germany. Reflecting upon the lessons learned from theory and practice, we conclude that crucial starting points for systemic sustainability innovations can be found in values-based networks and business models.
Towards Values-Based Innovation Management
In order to specify the potential of values-based innovation, we need to differentiate between various management levels and the impact of different types of values. Building on The Integrated Management Concept (building on Bleicher), we distinguish between three dimensions of management in general and innovation management in particular. These are the normative, strategic, and instrumental management dimensions (Fig. 1).
Fig. 1: Values (left) impact normative, strategic and instrumental management and may be leveraged to inform innovation activities (right) such as innovation in values-based networks.
Our framework describes how a company’s values and normative orientations — constituted of corporate governance, policy and culture, and articulated, for instance, in vision or mission statements — frame strategies and operations and thus business model-related decisions. Figure 1 relates the three innovation management dimensions to exemplary values on the left and broad innovation categories (called “innovation levers”) associated with these dimensions on the right.
A full overview of this framework, a discussion of different types of values and their impact on innovation is given in our new book “Values-Based Innovation Management” (Breuer & Lüdeke-Freund, 2017).
A Framework and Workshop Method for Values-Based Business Modelling
In order to facilitate the ideation and development of values-based networks and business models, and thereby translate the theoretical framework described above into an actionable management approach, we combined a “future workshop” format (workshop part 1) and business modelling techniques (workshop part 2) (Fig. 2).
Fig. 2: A framework and workshop method for values-based network and business model innovation.
Workshop part 1: Future workshop
A “future workshop” consists of three phases of critique, vision (or fantasy) and realisation. This format allows directing collaborative reasoning in the critique phase towards values that are neglected or counteracted in the current situation. In the visionary phase, participants are asked, which ideal values could be achieved in a Utopian setting, i.e., in the best of all cases. They are also asked to provide live graphic recordings of emerging associations and ideas to enhance their imagination. In the realisation phase, participants generate ideas on how to realise selected aspects of their ideal values and on how the different participating actors could contribute to the realisation of these values.
Workshop part 2: Business modelling
The second workshop part shown in Fig. 3 is dedicated to business model and network development using the Business Innovation Kit. The toolkit contains self-explanatory instructions guiding workshop teams through the definition of values or a “common ground”, exemplification (through cases and business model patterns), ideation (for single business model components), modelling relations across components and models, and challenging implicit assumptions with scenarios. The layout of this tool supports values-based, and thus also sustainability-oriented, modelling in collaborative settings and accounts for the participants’ varying and potentially conflicting values and normative orientations.
The framework and method have been applied to a case of developing a sustainable energy region. This case and its results are discussed in an article published in the International Journal of Innovation Management.
Breuer, H. & Lüdeke-Freund, F. (2017, in print): Values-Based Network and Business Model Innovation, Int. Journal of Innovation Management, Vol. 21, No. 3, Art. 1750028 (35 pages). Research Gate
Breuer, H. & Lüdeke-Freund, F. (2017): Values-Based Innovation Management – Innovating by What We Care About. Houndmills: Palgrave. Book Website